The classical warrior trained out of dire necessity and for the purpose of survival. The advent of modern martial arts, however, have created a new paradigm: the martial hobbyist. Is the study of the martial ways still worthy of a lifelong pursuit, or has commercialism relegated them to just being another pastime? Can your bi-weekly karate class be put on a par with bowling, tennis or some similar recreation?
Is there anything wrong with that?
Before anyone launches into a diatribe about how
bushido is a calling or starts reciting scripture from
The Art of War, bear in mind that the modern practitioner is a
consumer; the school owner/chief instructor is a merchant. This greatly affects the martial arts in the way they are presented to, and viewed by the student. It should go without saying that the classical warrior took his training with utmost sincerity and seriousness; his very life depended on it. But times have changed. The martial arts' "serious" edge has been irrevocably dulled by modernism. In his writings, Donn Draeger expressed contempt for what he felt was a dismantling of the classical traditions of
budo - the martial ways:
Classical budo is not a trifling matter begun for fun or whim. And it is not to be engaged in for personal pleasure or social amusement. Those who would seek to use the dojo for refined exhibitionism, peacock pride, social climbing, chitchat, or gossip have failed to grasp the fact that the profundity of the classical budo exceeds love of self.
Now that's serious. Ironically in his personal life, Draeger had a reputation for being a prankster and a hell-raiser, but I digress. I don't mean to mock this way of thinking, rather my point is that I feel it is up to the student how to approach training in the martial arts. Depending on the person, like it or not, there will be those who regard the dojo as either a temple, a school, or a hangout. It's their personal business; just train hard and go about your own business. Even for those who aspire to black belt or teach, very few are cut out for the dedicated long haul.